- "On the other hand... No one said you always have to listen to your conscience."
- —Alice's conscience to Alice
Callie makes a difficult decision after the Anwei International case goes forward. Mariana struggles with her feelings for Evan while Raj bonds with her new roommate Isabella. Alice's relationship with Joey is put in jeopardy.
- Maia Mitchell as Callie Adams Foster
- Cierra Ramirez as Mariana Adams Foster
- Zuri Adele as Malika Williams (credit only)
- Sherry Cola as Alice Kwan
- Emma Hunton as Davia Moss (credit only)
- Tommy Martinez as Gael Martinez (mentioned: credit only)
- Josh Pence as Dennis Cooper (credit only)
- Daisy Eagan as Joey Riverton
- Kara Wang as Sumi
- Rhea Butcher as Lindsay Brady
- Priscilla Quintana as Isabella
- Dhruv Uday Singh as Raj Patil
- T.J. Linnard as Evan Speck
- Beau Mirchoff as Jamie Hunter
- Amin El Gamal as Cary Plack
- Juan Antonio as Marcus
- Nicole Lynn Evans as Gwen Tuckerman
- Lisandra Tina as Teresa
- Seri DeYoung as Claire
- Rachel Rosenbloom as Gina
- Maisie Klompus as Rachel
Notes and Trivia
- "In Good Conscience" is the second episode, following only "Gumboot Becky", in which promotional images were not released.
- Joey and Alice break up.